By any regular metric, the Turning Level USA “All-American Halftime Present” was an enormous failure. At its peak, it had 6.1 million concurrent views, which could sound good till you study that the precise NFL halftime present with Unhealthy Bunny had 135 million based mostly on preliminary stories. If that quantity holds, it is going to be the most-watched halftime present ever, knocking final yr’s Kendrick Lamar present from the highest spot.
Another that couldn’t even pull 5% of the real-time eyeballs affixed to the dreaded Bunny just isn’t successful, full cease. iIn a traditional world, instantly saying that you just have been going to do it another time in 2027 could be deeply odd and delusional.
However the pathetically low viewership doesn’t matter, as a result of the purpose of the TPUSA halftime present was to gin up outrage over the actual halftime present, to not create a well-produced, well-run, or well-performed occasion. And with a lot right-wing cash sloshing round, there isn’t a stress for something like this to succeed. It simply has to come back into being.
Notably, the TPUSA present was additionally not successful as a present. It wasn’t filmed wherever recognizable and ended up trying just like the performers had wandered onstage at CPAC. Headliner Child Rock’s lip-syncing was off. TPUSA head Erika Kirk couldn’t be bothered to attend. Not precisely a world-class occasion.
This was by no means a severe enterprise. Artists weren’t even finalized till per week earlier than the Tremendous Bowl, regardless of being introduced in October. That form of delay might need been tremendous if TPUSA had finally revealed some wonderful heavy hitter, however as an alternative it coughed up the infinitely washed-up Child Rock and three different nation singers who have been under no circumstances family names however did have the requisite MAGA grievance politics.
If something, this haphazard slop reveals a whole disregard and disdain for TPUSA followers, Child Rock followers, and followers of the also-rans: a last-minute lineup, a shitty venue, and no precise broadcast rights. Only a rapidly assembled, low-rent occasion whose function was to not present individuals with high quality leisure however to function a technique to howl about Unhealthy Bunny.
Nonetheless, there may be a powerful degree of post-show flop sweat as conservatives attempt to inform themselves what an enormous success this factor was. Proper-wing activist Jack Posobiec declared the occasion was the primary YouTube livestream of all time in numerous classes and that Child Rock’s sizzling new launch handed Unhealthy Bunny on iTunes, however with none, you understand, proof.
However by noon on Monday, Posobiec was bragging that someway 40-50 million individuals watched the factor on some mixture of reside and streaming and platforms and no matter and due to this fact, as Posobiec stated, “VOTED WITH THEIR REMOTE CONTROLS LAST NIGHT.”
Besides that’s clearly not true. Even when someway 40-50 million individuals actually did tune in to see Child Rock beclown himself, it didn’t make a dent within the official halftime present numbers. There was no mass voting through distant management, with individuals clicking away from Unhealthy Bunny. As an alternative, it seems that Unhealthy Bunny put up the most important halftime numbers ever.
That is clearly some self-soothing for Posobiec, but it surely isn’t actually obligatory. The cash will all the time be there for subsequent yr’s various halftime present, as a result of TPUSA had income of $85 million in 2024 alone. Beneath Charlie Kirk, the group raised $389 million from 2012 to 2023, and conservative billionaires simply love to present the group cash. Even the existence of the choice halftime present was a fundraising alternative.
At first look, the MAGA leisure world appears much like the closed world of evangelical leisure that has been round for many years. Nonetheless, that stuff is really fashionable, albeit with a restricted market. It’s telling that TPUSA didn’t pull any of these high-profile Christian recording artists, who arguably could be aligned with TPUSA’s values. As an alternative, they acquired a has-been who has a tune bragging about statutory rape and a few Nashville denizens whose telephones aren’t ringing as a lot as they used to.
The precise having such an amazing sum of money warps the incentives right here. Nobody must placed on a great present. Nobody must get good scores. Exterior metrics are meaningless as a result of the purpose was to not really dethrone the NFL halftime present, a ridiculous proposition even when TPUSA had landed huge performers. The purpose was simply to be indignant, to scream about Unhealthy Bunny, and to supply a tepid, half-assed various that conservatives are pressured to fake was terrific.
That’s true of Bari Weiss at CBS simply as a lot as right here. Usually, coming in and having your scores instantly nosedive and making bizarre selections to place your self on digicam regardless of being in no way good at it could be severe missteps for a brand new chief.
However Weiss isn’t there to do good work. She’s there to push a right-wing agenda. And when she isn’t doing that, she’s acquired probably the most low-rent materials conceivable, like placing her sister on air to speak a few random Free Press piece.
It’s additionally true of “Melania,” the documentary that was actually only a means for Jeff Bezos to bribe the president. Bezos spent $40 million to make the factor and one other $35 million on promoting. Keen conservatives with smaller pocketbooks then had their very own alternative to suck as much as Trump by buying huge quantities of tickets to artificially prop up gross sales.
However these strikes solely work one time, so gross sales for the second week of this epic story dropped 67%. As with the TPUSA halftime present, there’s an try to fake the movie is an precise actual piece of artwork and that folks actually wish to see it, however why hassle? The movie has already served its twin functions: letting Trump know simply how far Bezos will go to curry favor and giving conservatives speaking factors about how Actual America craves this form of factor.
At greatest, these items is a waste of time, at worst, pure propaganda. However so many individuals behind it are in such an insular world that they’ve satisfied themselves that everybody shares their fixations. Usually, that insularity could be pierced by the constant failures of those tasks, however with all that candy right-wing money, that by no means occurs. These people will proceed making rage bait for one another, all of the whereas telling themselves they’re talking to nearly all of Individuals.
