Essentially the most generally banned books in U.S. faculties embody LGBTQ titles, worldwide bestsellers, teen romantasy novels and a 1962 traditional, in accordance with a brand new report that compares modern-day censorship to Chilly Warfare-era McCarthyism.
Greater than 6,800 e-book bans had been enacted throughout the 2024-25 faculty 12 months in 87 public faculty districts throughout 23 states, in accordance with a report launched Wednesday by PEN America, a nonprofit that advocates free of charge expression. The report was launched forward of Banned Books Week, which begins Sunday.
“Censorship pressures have expanded and escalated,” Kasey Meehan, director of PEN America’s Freedom to Learn program, mentioned in a information launch. “A disturbing ‘on a regular basis banning’ and normalization of censorship has worsened and unfold during the last 4 years.”
The group’s annual “Banned within the USA” report says the present atmosphere of “unfettered e-book banning is harking back to the Pink Scare of the Fifties.” It defines a faculty e-book ban as “any motion taken in opposition to a e-book based mostly on its content material and on account of mother or father or group challenges, administrative choices, or in response to direct or threatened motion by governmental officers” that results in the e-book being eliminated or restricted.
The newest report discovered that 3,752 distinctive titles had been affected by bans within the faculty 12 months that resulted in June. Essentially the most banned titles included “A Clockwork Orange” and “Depraved,” whereas probably the most banned authors included Stephen King, Sarah J. Maas and Jodi Picoult. Greater than 80% of all bans originated in simply three states: Florida, Texas and Tennessee.
This previous faculty 12 months noticed fewer complete bans than in 2023-24, at greater than 10,000, although the quantity is much above the place it was in 2021-22 (greater than 2,500 bans), when PEN America first began to compile an annual report. Since July 2021, PEN America has tracked 22,810 e-book bans throughout 45 states.
One motive the entire variety of e-book bans could have dipped this 12 months is that some titles are being pre-emptively taken off the cabinets.
“This capabilities as a type of ‘obeying upfront’ to anticipated restrictions from the state or administrative authorities, rooted in concern or just a want to keep away from subjects that is likely to be deemed controversial,” the report states.
One other potential motive, as writer Malinda Lo identified, is that beforehand banned titles haven’t returned to cabinets. Lo, whose e-book “Final Evening on the Telegraph Membership” was No. 4 on PEN America’s new listing, mentioned on Instagram that her 2021 novel made the reduce “partly as a result of all the standard titles like ‘Gender Queer’ have already been banned and eliminated.”
“As soon as a e-book is banned, it’s gone,” she wrote on Wednesday. “That is why now we have to maintain preventing these assaults on our first modification rights.”
“Gender Queer,” a graphic memoir that debuted in 2019, was No. 1 on PEN America’s Most Banned Books Record in 2022, although it didn’t even make the highest 15 on this 12 months’s listing.
Books with LGBTQ themes and characters — like “Gender Queer” and “Final Evening on the Telegraph Membership” — are constantly among the many most banned books highlighted within the annual stories of PEN America and the American Library Affiliation, and this 12 months is not any totally different.
Listed below are the 15 most banned books this previous faculty 12 months as tracked by PEN America, ranked so as of these banned by probably the most public faculty districts throughout the nation:
‘A Clockwork Orange’ by Anthony Burgess
Burgess’ dystopian satire a couple of sociopathic, Beethoven-obsessed teen gang chief was banned in 23 districts within the 2024-25 faculty 12 months. The 1962 novel was tailored into an Oscar-nominated movie by Stanley Kubrick in 1971 and was named considered one of Time’s 100 greatest English-language novels and considered one of Fashionable Library’s 100 Greatest Novels.
‘Breathless’ by Jennifer Niven
Niven’s 2020 novel is a coming-of-age love story that was banned in 20 faculty districts. On her web site, the bestselling writer describes “Breathless” as “the e-book I wanted once I was sixteen, seventeen, eighteen. A frank tackle intercourse and love, parental divorce, discovering your self, and the significance of writing your story. Of writing your life.”
‘Bought’ by Patricia McCormick
McCormick’s young-adult novel, a couple of woman from Nepal who’s offered into sexual slavery in India, was banned in 20 faculty districts within the final faculty 12 months. This 2006 title was a Nationwide E book Award finalist and was on the Writer’s Weekly Greatest Books of the Yr listing and the ALA’s High Ten Books for Younger Adults listing.
‘Final Evening on the Telegraph Membership’ by Malinda Lo
Lo’s young-adult historic novel about love and responsibility in Fifties San Francisco was banned in 19 faculty districts within the 2024-25 faculty 12 months. The critically acclaimed 2021 novel received a protracted listing of awards, together with a Nationwide E book Award, Stonewall E book Award and Asian/Pacific American Award for Literature.
‘A Courtroom of Mist and Fury’ by Sarah J. Maas
This bestselling grownup romantasy novel, which was banned in 18 districts within the 2024-25 faculty 12 months, is the second e-book in Maas’ wildly in style “A Courtroom of Thorns and Roses” collection. Maas, the one writer with a couple of title on this prime 15 listing, additionally has the excellence of being some of the banned authors this 12 months, with 162 complete bans, behind solely Stephen King and “Crank” writer Ellen Hopkins.
‘Crank’ by Ellen Hopkins
Hopkins’ 2004 young-adult novel was banned in 17 faculty districts. On her web site, the writer revealed this bestseller is loosely based mostly on her “older daughter’s story of dependancy to crystal meth.” She mentioned “Crank” started as “a private exploration of the ‘why’s’ behind my daughter’s choices, and what half I may need performed in them.”
‘Endlessly…’ by Judy Blume
Blume’s award-winning 1975 young-adult novel, which was banned in 17 districts within the final faculty 12 months, has been a goal of censorship for 50 years, in accordance with PEN America. Blume mentioned she wrote the e-book — which was named considered one of NPR’s 100 Greatest-Ever Teen Novels and Time’s 100 Greatest YA Books of All Time — as a result of her daughter “requested for a narrative about two good children who’ve intercourse with out both of them having to die.”
‘The Perks of Being a Wallflower’ by Stephen Chbosky
Chbosky’s 2009 coming-of-age novel about an observant “wallflower” navigating the “unusual world between adolescence and maturity” was banned in 17 faculty districts within the 2024-25 faculty 12 months. The No. 1 New York Occasions bestseller — which offers with subjects together with first dates, household drama, intercourse, medication and suicide — was tailored right into a 2012 movie starring Logan Lerman, Emma Watson and Ezra Miller.
‘Depraved’ by Gregory Maguire
This No. 1 New York Occasions bestseller, which debuted in 1995 and is a reimagined prequel to “The Great Wizard of Oz,” was banned in 17 faculty districts. The story of “Depraved,” nonetheless, is probably greatest recognized resulting from its adaptation right into a Tony-winning Broadway musical and an Oscar-winning musical movie starring Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande.
‘All Boys Aren’t Blue’ by George M. Johnson
Johnson’s 2020 memoir-manifesto about coming of age as a queer Black man was banned in 16 districts within the final faculty 12 months, and it additionally topped the ALA’s listing of 10 most challenged library books of 2024. In an interview with NBC Information final 12 months, Johnson mentioned the actual e-book censorship hazard lies within the “soft-banning”: “We are able to monitor the books which are being banned, however we will’t monitor books that aren’t being ordered.”
‘A Courtroom of Thorns and Roses’ by Sarah J. Maas
The primary e-book in Maas’ internationally bestselling five-book romantasy collection was, just like the remaining books on this listing, banned in 16 faculty districts. The central character in 2015’s “A Courtroom of Thorns and Roses” is 19-year-old Feyre, an ethical huntress who’s dragged to a magical land and falls for her immortal captor.
‘Damsel’ by Elana Okay. Arnold
This darkish and twisted fairy story, a 2019 Michael L. Printz Award Honor E book, is, on the floor, a couple of damsel who’s rescued from a dragon by a good-looking prince. Previous to “Damsel,” Arnold’s e-book “What Women Are Made Of” was a finalist for the 2017 Nationwide E book Award in Younger Individuals’s Literature.
‘The DUFF’ by Kody Keplinger
In Keplinger’s 2010 young-adult novel, 17-year-old Bianca discovers her highschool’s “slimy faculty hottie” has given her an offensive nickname — DUFF, or Designated Ugly Fats Buddy — however she nonetheless results in a “closeted enemies-with-benefits relationship” with him. Keplinger was solely 17 herself when she wrote this bestselling e-book, which was tailored right into a 2015 movie.
‘Nineteen Minutes’ by Jodi Picoult
This No. 1 New York Occasions bestseller is in regards to the aftermath of a faculty taking pictures in a small New Hampshire city. Revealed in 2007, that is considered one of 29 novels written by Picoult, whose different works embody “My Sister’s Keeper,” “Small Nice Issues” and “The Pact.”
‘Storm and Fury’ by Jennifer L. Armentrout
Armentrout’s 2019 romantasy novel is the primary e-book in her three-book “Harbinger” collection. “Storm and Fury” is centered on 18-year-old Trinity Marrow, who “could also be going blind” however “can see and talk with ghosts and spirits,” in accordance with Armentrout’s web site.
